Juicy New York Strip Steak Topped with Garlic Butter

Experience the unparalleled flavor and tenderness of a perfectly cooked New York strip steak, elevated with a rich, aromatic garlic and herb butter. This guide will walk you through creating a restaurant-quality steak right in your own kitchen. Forget expensive steakhouse bills; achieve that golden-brown sear and succulent interior with our easy-to-follow method, ensuring a memorable meal every time.

There’s nothing quite like a fantastic steak to make any meal feel special. While a simple pan-seared steak is a delight on its own, adding a savory mushroom sauce or slicing it for vibrant fajitas can transform your dining experience. Today, we’re focusing on the classic New York strip, enhanced with an incredibly flavorful garlic and herb butter that melts into every bite.

Understanding the New York Strip Steak

The New York strip steak, also known as a strip loin or Kansas City strip, is a cut derived from the short loin of a cow. This particular muscle group is not heavily utilized by the animal, which contributes to the steak’s remarkable tenderness. When sold boneless, it’s commonly referred to as a New York strip. It strikes an excellent balance between tenderness and rich, beefy flavor, often at a more accessible price point compared to cuts like filet mignon or ribeye, making it a fantastic choice for home cooks.

A good New York strip steak typically features a nice cap of fat along one side, which renders down during cooking, adding to its succulence and flavor. Its moderate marbling (the streaks of fat within the muscle) ensures a juicy and flavorful steak. When selecting your steaks, look for cuts that are uniformly thick (about 1 to 1.5 inches), have good marbling, and a vibrant red color. Avoid steaks that look greyish or have excess liquid in the packaging.

The Art of Cooking New York Strip Steak to Perfection

Achieving a steakhouse-quality New York strip at home is surprisingly simple, relying on a few key techniques. The combination of high-heat searing and oven-finishing ensures a beautiful crust while maintaining a perfectly cooked interior. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the process:

**Bring to Room Temperature:** Remove your New York strip steaks from the refrigerator about 20-30 minutes before cooking. Allowing them to come closer to room temperature promotes more even cooking throughout the steak, preventing a cold center and an overcooked exterior.
**Pat Dry and Season Generously:** Before seasoning, thoroughly pat the steaks dry with paper towels. Excess moisture on the surface will hinder the searing process, steaming the meat instead of creating that desired golden-brown crust. Season both sides liberally with coarse salt and freshly ground black pepper. Don’t be shy with the seasoning; a good steak can handle it, and it’s crucial for flavor development.
**Preheat Your Oven:** Set your oven to 450 degrees Fahrenheit (232 degrees Celsius). This will be used to finish the steaks after searing.
**Heat the Pan:** Place a heavy-bottomed pan, ideally a cast iron skillet, over high heat. Allow the pan to get screaming hot – this is vital for achieving a good sear. You’ll know it’s hot enough when a drop of water sizzles and evaporates instantly.
**Add Oil and Sear:** Add a high smoke point, neutral-flavored oil to the hot pan. Carefully place the seasoned strip steaks in the pan in a single layer, ensuring not to overcrowd it. If cooking more than two steaks, consider searing in batches to maintain high pan temperature. Sear for 3-4 minutes per side, or until a beautiful deep golden-brown crust forms. This is the Maillard reaction at work, developing complex flavors and a satisfying texture.
**Butter Basting with Aromatics:** Once both sides are seared, reduce the heat to medium-low. Add several tablespoons of butter to the pan. As the butter melts, add smashed garlic cloves and fresh thyme sprigs (or other preferred herbs). Tilt the pan slightly and, using a spoon, continuously baste the melted, herb-infused butter over the steaks for about 1-2 minutes. This infuses the steak with incredible flavor and helps keep it moist.
**Finish in the Oven:** Immediately transfer the pan with the steaks to the preheated oven. Cook for 5-7 minutes, or until your desired internal temperature is reached (see temperature guide below). For a medium steak, aim for around 140 degrees F. Using a digital probe thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the steak is the most accurate way to gauge doneness.
**Rest the Steak:** This is arguably the most critical step for a juicy steak. Remove the pan from the oven and transfer the steaks to a cutting board. Let them rest for at least 5-10 minutes. During this time, the juices, which have been pushed to the center by the heat, redistribute evenly throughout the meat. If you slice too early, all those delicious juices will run out onto your board, leaving you with a drier steak. Spoon any remaining pan drippings over the rested steaks before slicing.
**Slice and Serve:** Slice the New York strip against the grain into thick, even pieces. Drizzle with the pan juices and serve immediately.

Essential Tips for the Perfect New York Strip

**Choose the Right Pan:** A heavy-bottomed pan, such as a cast iron skillet or an enameled cast iron pan, is highly recommended. These pans retain heat exceptionally well, which is crucial for achieving that beautiful, dark crust on your steak. A stainless steel pan can also work if it’s sufficiently heavy.
**Experiment with Herbs:** While garlic and thyme are a classic and delicious pairing, don’t hesitate to experiment with other fresh herbs. Rosemary, sage, or a sprinkle of fresh parsley or basil added at the very end of cooking can introduce different aromatic profiles and elevate the flavor.
**Serving and Storage:** For the best experience, serve your steak immediately after the resting period. Any leftovers should be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. To reheat, gently warm on the stovetop over low heat or in the microwave on a low setting, being careful not to overcook and dry out the meat.
**High Smoke Point Oil:** The choice of oil is crucial for a good sear. Always use a neutral-flavored oil with a high smoke point to prevent burning and imparting off-flavors. Excellent options include canola oil, corn oil, grapeseed oil, safflower oil, and peanut oil. Olive oil, particularly extra virgin, has a lower smoke point and is not ideal for high-heat searing.
**Perfect Side Dish Pairings:** A magnificent steak deserves equally delicious accompaniments. Classic pairings include creamy mashed potatoes, crispy roasted green beans, asparagus, creamed spinach, or a simple garden salad. Consider a bold red wine to complement the rich flavors of the beef.
**Don’t Overcrowd the Pan:** If you’re cooking multiple steaks, sear them in batches. Overcrowding the pan will lower its temperature, causing the steaks to steam rather than sear, resulting in a less desirable crust.

Achieving Your Desired Steak Temperature

The most reliable way to ensure your New York strip steak reaches your preferred level of doneness is by using a digital probe thermometer. Insert the thermometer into the thickest part of the steak, avoiding any bone. Remember that steaks will continue to cook slightly after being removed from the heat – a phenomenon known as “carry-over cooking.” Therefore, it’s best to remove the meat a few degrees below your target temperature.

Always allow your cooked strip steaks to rest for at least 5-10 minutes before slicing. This resting period is crucial for the juices to redistribute throughout the meat, resulting in a more tender and juicy steak.

Here’s a general guide for internal steak temperatures:

**Rare:** 125-130 degrees F (52-54 C)
**Medium Rare:** 130-135 degrees F (54-57 C) – often considered the ideal for tenderness and juiciness.
**Medium:** 135-140 degrees F (57-60 C) – my personal preference for a balanced cook.
**Medium Well:** 140-145 degrees F (60-63 C)
**Well Done:** 150 degrees F (66 C) and above – generally not recommended as it can lead to a tough and dry steak.

This recipe for New York strip steak with garlic butter is a true culinary gem – simple enough for a busy weeknight yet elegant and impressive for entertaining guests. The rich, savory flavors and tender texture will undoubtedly make it a new favorite in your repertoire.

Explore More Steak Recipes

Steak Tacos
The Best Steak Marinade
Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
Garlic Butter Steak Bites
Steak Kabobs

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars from 60 votes

New York Strip Steak with Garlic Butter

Print Recipe |
Pin Recipe

Author: Sara Welch

Seared New York strip steak served in garlic butter.

This New York strip steak is seared to golden brown perfection, then topped with a luscious garlic and herb butter. An easy dinner recipe that tastes like it came from a steakhouse, but can be made in the comfort of your own home.

Time: Prep Time: 10 minutes | Cook Time: 15 minutes | Total Time: 25 minutes

Course: Main

Cuisine: American

Serves: 4

Ingredients

4 New York strip steaks (8-10 ounces each)
1 1/2 tablespoons neutral flavored oil (such as corn oil, safflower oil, canola oil, grapeseed oil or peanut oil)
Salt and pepper to taste
4 tablespoons butter
4 garlic cloves, smashed
5 sprigs fresh thyme

Instructions

Let the steaks sit at room temperature for 20 minutes.
Preheat the oven to 450 degrees F (232 C). Season the steaks generously on both sides with salt and pepper to taste.
Heat a heavy pan such as a cast iron skillet over high heat until very hot.
Add the oil to the pan. Place the strip steaks in the pan in a single layer.
Cook for 3-4 minutes per side or until a deep golden-brown crust forms.
Add the butter to the pan. After the butter has melted, add the smashed garlic cloves and thyme sprigs to the pan. Stir to combine.
Spoon the butter mixture over the steaks, continuously basting for about 1-2 minutes. Insert a probe thermometer into the thickest part of one of the steaks.
Place the pan with the meat in the oven and bake for 5-7 minutes or until the thermometer registers 140 degrees F (60 C) for a medium steak.
Remove the pan from the oven. Let the steak rest for 5-10 minutes on a cutting board. Spoon the pan drippings over the steak, then slice against the grain and serve immediately.

Nutrition (per serving)

Did you make this recipe? Tag @dinneratthezoo on Instagram and hashtag it #dinneratthezoo!

Share it with the world

Facebook |
Twitter |
Pinterest